How to Steal a Dog by Barbara O'Connor Continued
The second half of this book was
very different than the first half of this book. The morality and consciousness
of Georgina was much more apparent in this portion of the book. I was very happy
to see the character growth and progression throughout this book because in the
first half of the story I found myself incredibly irritated and annoyed at
Georgina’s attitude. She often complained about her mom and their living
situation. It seemed like the relationships Georgina had with both her mom and
her brother improved throughout the last half of the book. Georgina realizes
her mother is trying very hard to improve their lifestyle and get them back into
an apartment or home. It came across as if Georgina gained respect for her mom
and the sacrifices she has made for their family. She finally acknowledged that
their living situation isn’t all their moms fault. The relationship with her
brother also improved. In the first half of the book Georgina’s approach to her
brother was as if it was a burden or an annoyance. She dragged him along
throughout her plan to steal the dog. However, in the second half of the book
she interacts with her brother in a more respectful way. They work together
more to take care of Willy, rather than Georgina controlling Toby.
Regarding the aspect of her consciousness and morality I think Georgina made strides in improving her personal attitude and behavior. After stealing the dog, she finds out the owner, Carmella, doesn’t even have the money to pay for a reward. While she is pressured to talk to relatives and find help to come up with the money she is unsuccessful in doing so. Carmella, just like Georgina, is in a tough situation. I think this is a good lesson for Georgina because she was so quick to judge Carmella by her name and the house that she didn’t consider something may be going on in her life as well. The interaction with Carmella as well Mookie, a homeless man living in the abandoned building where they keep Willy, help Georgina realize she has made a wrong choice and she should have listened to her hesitations from the beginning. Because of the advice from Mookie as well as Toby, Georgina confesses what she has done and realizes the error in her ways. I believe she made the plans with good intentions but did not think of how it would affect other people. The lessons she learned from Mookie and Carmela will stick with her as she makes those kinds of important and drastic decisions.
I really enjoyed the last part of
this book, especially in comparison to the beginning. However, one aspect of
the book seemed rushed and somewhat unfitting with story. They have been going
through all of these trial and problems in their life and all of the sudden
Georgina’s family has a home to live in. I was glad their situation turned
around. It just seemed like a stereotypical fairy-tale ending, where everything
is perfect and well at the end. I think the purpose for this in this text is to
show that Georgina made the right decision and was honest and in the end when
we do things correctly, we work hard and we are honest we will reach our goals.
I believed this to be one of the major themes and messages of the story.
Overall I enjoyed this book. It
was much different than I thought it would be, but in a good and thought
provoking way.
I found it is interesting how we have some different views on Georgina's relationships with her family. I found that Georgina had the attitude kind of like "about time" they got a house. I also thought she treated Toby like a minion helping her do her bidding. Although there were times where she was happy to talk to Toby, and wanted him to be happy. I also had a different outlook when you stated:
ReplyDelete" I think this is a good lesson for Georgina because she was so quick to judge Carmella by her name and the house that she didn’t consider something may be going on in her life as well."
I mainly disagree because even after Georgina and Toby went in the Carmella's house they were still encouraging her to pay a lot of money to get back Willy. I would have thought that if she had a understanding of her financial problems she wouldn't have kept pushing. But she did come around at the end of the book.
Lastly, I agree with you that there was a quick turn around from a depressing theme through out the book to a happy ending with in the last few pages of the book.
I feel the same way you do in regards to how different both sections of the book were. I really feel like she turned a corner in the second half of the book. The first half, she seemed to be a lot more rebellious and wreckless with her behavior, she did not care who she hurt or what the outcome of her actions were. Compared to the second half, she was a lot more thoughtful about her actions and the things she did. This was noticeable when she began to regret stealing Willy and getting the reward for "finding" him. It was interesting how at the end all of the circumstances they were going through were solved within one or two chapters which was a bit of a bummer, though I honestly enjoyed the reading.
ReplyDeleteI am glad that you were able to enjoy the book, because I did not. I really agree about the depressing tone that was displayed throughout the book, and how it was so nicely wrapped up in the end. Wrapping up a story in a nice neat bow, like everything is going to be just fine and dandy after such a horrible experience does not sit well with me. Even if it is children's literature. Maybe I am the sick and twisted, but that is my personal opinion. I am really glad that you were able to appreciate Georgina gaining a sense of morality, and an understanding of how her behavior was unacceptable. I wish I could have enjoyed the book.
ReplyDelete